19 chapters
The Chandler Development Group story
From the public record, in time order. Each number in brackets links to its source.
Chandler Development Group in the public record
Chandler Development Group Inc. was registered in British Columbia on January 7, 2002, and has carried that name since May 22, 2002, according to the provincial registry. The registry has listed it as historical, meaning no longer active, since July 2009. The City's business licence records show it with an office at 1168 Hamilton Street in Yaletown from 2004 to 2006, and at 601 West Cordova Street in 2007. The 2008 licence record is marked as gone out of business.[5],[6]
The record ties the company to five residential buildings: H&H at 1133 Homer Street, the two Garden City towers in Richmond, Tribeca Lofts at 988 Richards Street and Hamlin Mews on Oak Street. City approval records, court filings and news reports confirm H&H and Garden City. For Tribeca Lofts and Hamlin Mews, the link comes from the company's own 2006 marketing and from property listing sites, while City records describe the sites themselves.[1],[4],[13],[23],[22],[20]
The companies behind each project
Each project had a company of its own. The H&H site belonged to Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd., registered on December 19, 2003, which took that name on July 28, 2004. The Garden City towers belonged to Cook and Katsura Homes Inc., a company first registered on October 3, 1996, which took that name on July 9, 2004. The registry lists the Richmond company as historical since April 2009, the Homer Street company since June 2009 and Chandler Development Group Inc. since July 2009.[10],[11],[5]
The court-appointed receiver's report of January 2008 deals with the two project companies together, and its tables call them the Chandler Group of Companies and the Chandler Projects. CBC News reported in February 2008 that both projects belonged to Chandler Development Group Inc. The receiver's figures also show construction management fees on both projects for a company named CDG Construction Ltd.[4],[13]
Other companies carry similar names. The provincial registry lists Chandler Development Inc., registered in 2003, and the City's licence records list Chandler Associates Architecture Inc. at 601 West Cordova Street, the same building as Chandler Development Group's office in 2007. Each has its own entry, and none of the records cited here names either one together with Chandler Development Group.[26],[6]
Mark Chandler, the developer named in 2006
A promotional feature in Urban Trendz in June 2006 says developer Mark Chandler hosted the H&H groundbreaking on Tuesday, May 16, 2006, together with Bob Rennie, who led marketing and sales for the tower. In April 2018, Business in Vancouver described Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd. as Mark Chandler's company, in a report on a later project of his in Langley.[7],[8]
The Langley Advance Times reported in 2023 that Mark Chandler holds Canadian and British citizenship and was involved in the mid-2000s in projects to build condo towers in Vancouver and Richmond. The same report says this came after a 2003 guilty plea to theft in Arizona, after which he was deported from the United States, given three years of probation and ordered to pay $189,550 in restitution.[9]
Business in Vancouver also reported in 2018 that the Supreme Court of British Columbia froze $35 million of Mark Chandler's assets in 2007, in a case separate from the receivership, after investors alleged that he had misrepresented real estate deals and forged a mortgage document. The report does not say how that case ended.[8]
How the company described itself in 2006
The company's H&H advertising in 2006 called it a "respected family firm, with more than three generations of extensive real estate experience in Vancouver and beyond". That is the company's own description, printed in a promotional feature in Real Estate Weekly on February 10, 2006. The same feature says the company was known for Tribeca Lofts in Yaletown, Hamlin Mews at 38th Avenue and Oak Street, and Garden City in Richmond. A June 2006 feature in Urban Trendz names the same three and calls the Richmond project Parkside at Garden City, two towers it describes as next to a 21-acre park.[23],[7]
The February feature announced that the H&H showroom at 1066 Richards Street would open for previews on Saturday, February 18, 2006, and advertised prices from the $300,000s. Its photos are credited to Rennie Marketing. The City's licence records list Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd. at 1066 Richards Street in 2006 and 2007. The June feature advertised tower homes of 557 to 1,450 square feet and two-level townhomes of 1,180 to 1,256 square feet.[23],[7],[6]
Tribeca Lofts, 988 Richards Street
Tribeca Lofts stands at 988 Richards Street, at the corner of Nelson Street in Yaletown. On the City's 2026 tax roll its strata plan, BCS1920, holds 54 strata lots: 46 at 988 Richards Street, 4 with their own Richards Street numbers from 978 to 986, and 4 at 481 to 487 Nelson Street. BC Assessment gives 2006 as the year built for every lot that lists one. The site is in the City's downtown district zone.[22]
The company's 2006 marketing lists Tribeca Lofts among its projects and describes it as glass and brick homes in Yaletown. Two property sites, VADA Property Management and Condos.ca, list Chandler Development Group Inc. as the developer, and VADA gives 2006 as the year it was finished. The City approval records we could open for this address do not name the developer, so the link comes only from the company's claim and those listings.[7],[24],[21]
Hamlin Mews on Oak Street, 2004 to 2006
On February 24, 2004, City Council held a public hearing on an application by Formwerks Architectural to rezone 5312 to 5392 Oak Street, four lots on the block between West 37th and West 38th Avenues. The application asked to change the zoning from one-family homes to CD-1, a zone written for one site, for 21 two-storey townhouses at a floor space ratio of 1.0, meaning floor area equal to the site area. No one spoke for or against it, and Council approved it unanimously.[19]
Council's conditions asked for a continuous granite stone wall along every street edge and better design for the east ends, which face houses on 37th and 38th Avenues. The owner had to join the four lots into one, pave the lane from 37th to 38th Avenue and build a sidewalk on the north side of 38th Avenue. Jim Bussey of Formwerks Architectural answered Council's questions at the hearing.[19]
On the 2026 tax roll, strata plan BCS1746 holds 21 strata lots on that block, with Oak Street, West 37th Avenue and West 38th Avenue addresses, all zoned CD-1 (425) and all with 2006 as BC Assessment's year built. The company's 2006 marketing names Hamlin Mews among its projects, across from VanDusen Gardens at 38th and Oak, and Condos.ca lists Chandler Development Group as the builder of Hamlin Mews at 5326 Oak Street. The Council minutes name the architect as the applicant and do not name a developer.[20],[7],[21],[19]
Garden City, two towers in Richmond
Garden City is a pair of residential towers at Cook Road and Katsura Street in Richmond. SkyscraperPage, a building database, lists Garden City Residences I at 9188 Cook Road and Garden City Residences II at 6333 Katsura Street, each with 108 units and finished in 2008, with GBL Architects as architect and Chandler Development Group Inc. as developer. REW, a listing site, places both addresses on one strata plan, BCS2259, with 216 units.[17],[16],[18]
The receiver's 2010 paper describes Garden City as a two-tower development and gives different counts. By its account, the first tower had 106 units and was finished, with 94 of them sold and occupied, when the receivership began, while the second tower had 108 units and was 75 percent complete. The receiver took control of the second tower and of the 12 units still held in the first. The receiver's January 2008 report to the court gives the same 108 units for the tower it was finishing.[3],[4]
The corner of Homer and Helmcken, 2003 to 2005
The company that owned the land was Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd., registered on December 19, 2003. The City's 2006 permit report gives its address as the same Hamilton Street office where Chandler Development Group Inc. held its business licence. Its site was ten lots on the southwest corner of Homer and Helmcken Streets, 30,032 square feet in all, at the addresses 1101, 1107 and 1111 to 1119 Homer Street.[10],[1],[6]
The lots had commercial uses before. The permit report required three commercial driveway crossings to be removed, and it records a provincial Certificate of Compliance for 1101 Homer Street for commercial use on site. The receiver later told the court that the south part of the site, next to Helmcken Street, had been a gas station. The City's 2006 report lists three towers already on the block: the Robinson Tower across the lane at 488 Helmcken Street, the City Crest tower at 1155 Homer Street and a 24-storey tower at 1188 Richards Street.[1],[4]
The lots were joined into one parcel before construction. The City's 2007 tax roll lists a single parcel at 1133 Homer Street on plan BCP23923, assessed at $24,917,000, of which $20,339,000 was land. On the 2008 roll, with the building under construction, the parcel was assessed at $56,943,000. The strata lots first appear on the 2009 roll.[27]
The first design review and the neighbours, 2005
The architects, Hancock Brückner Eng & Wright, sent the first drawings to the City on February 14, 2005. The Urban Design Panel did not support the first version. The team cut the base by two storeys, and the architect told the Board it had met residents of the Robinson Tower and City Crest between the two reviews. The Panel then supported the revised plan unanimously on July 6, 2005.[1],[12]
At the Development Permit Board on September 26, 2005, the preliminary plan showed a 16-storey tower with 193 homes. City staff reported a 40-signature petition from the Robinson Tower and letters from City Crest. Two Robinson Tower residents spoke against the base, which reached 74 feet against a 70-foot guideline. The Board approved the plan in principle and ruled that the final plan would come back to the Board.[12]
Most of the Board's debate was about shadows. City staff found that a base two storeys lower would add sun to the corner of the Robinson Tower's deck only between 9 and 10 a.m. at the equinox, and that the tower's own shadow would cross the deck after that. One panel member said a stepped base at 74 feet was better than a straight one at 70 feet. The Board removed a proposed condition to cut one storey from the south face.[12]
Floor area bought from a Gastown heritage building
The site's zoning allowed floor area of five times the site area, and the developer asked for more through a heritage density transfer. Under that City program, the owner of a heritage building sells floor area to another site, and the heritage building is restored in return. The donor here was 46 Water Street, the Robinson Block, which the City's heritage data lists as a C building with municipal designation.[1],[12],[28]
The permit report says the donor, Blood Alley Holdings Inc., agreed to sell 15,000 square feet of heritage density to Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd. The 2005 plan used 10,025 square feet of it. After the design changes, the final plan used 5,187 square feet, 3.45 percent of the site's floor area, for a total of 5.18 times the site area.[1]
“In this respect, heritage density can be brought to the site up to 10% without providing a public amenity since the public value is seen as the restoration of a heritage building elsewhere.”
Approval, February 13, 2006
The complete application arrived on November 2, 2005. The City put up two signs on the site and mailed 1,825 letters to nearby owners. All six replies raised concerns, about density, shadows on 1090 Homer and 1188 Richards Streets, height and materials. City staff answered that the tower stayed within the 146-foot limit of the protected view, and that staff and the Urban Design Panel supported its design, which used brick on much of the outside.[1]
On February 13, 2006, the Development Permit Board approved the 16-storey building with 192 homes, 20 of them townhouses, and 223 parking spaces. The Board added a condition asking for brick or other quality materials on the blank south walls. It also required a Certificate of Compliance, or an equivalent document, for all ten lots before anyone moved in, after City staff said part of the site was still under study.[2],[1]
Building H&H, 2006 to 2007
Construction of H&H began with a groundbreaking on May 16, 2006, as the company's promotional feature that June describes it. The receiver later told the court that the company signed its concrete formwork and window supply contracts using drawings issued before the building permit was approved. The drawings then changed in large ways, and both contractors built to the revised plans and expected to be paid for the changes. By January 2008 the formwork contractor had claimed $221,503, and the receiver expected a claim of $300,000 from the window supplier.[7],[4]
Before the receivership, the company redesigned floors 15 and 16, turning six two-storey penthouses into four larger two-storey penthouses. The receiver told the court that this added 405 square feet over the floor area the permit allowed and cut the strata lots from 192 to 190, and that no application had been made to amend the development permit. Sales agreements had already been signed for all six penthouses on the permit drawings. City inspectors would not let work go on above floor 13 until the permit was amended.[4]
Receivership, November 2007 to March 2008
On November 28, 2007, in two separate orders, the Supreme Court of British Columbia appointed The Bowra Group Inc. as receiver-manager of Cook and Katsura Homes Inc. and Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd. A receiver-manager is an outside firm that a court puts in control of a company's property, so that its lenders can be repaid. The receiver's report says both projects had been due for completion by the end of June 2008.[4]
CBC News reported on February 28, 2008, that the receiver had been appointed to finish both buildings, pay the builders and deliver the homes. David Bowra, the receiver's president, told CBC that the company had cost overruns and was running out of cash, and that the lenders wanted the projects finished. He said the receiver had found 23 condos in the two projects that were allegedly sold to insiders at prices below market value. The Globe and Mail reported the two receiverships on March 7, 2008.[13],[15]
A 2010 paper by David Bowra and Heather Ferris of Lawson Lundell says H&H went into receivership after a lawsuit against the developer. By the paper's account, it had 9 unsold homes, $55 million of debt and an estimated $27 million left to build when the receiver took over. The paper also says the City had stopped work on the top three floors because of the penthouse change.[3]
- Debt at 7.75 percent a year$47,000,000
- Debt at 24 percent a year$5,200,000
- Debt at 16 percent a year$3,100,000
Total$55,300,000
The receiver's own figures, from a 2010 paper by its president and a Lawson Lundell lawyer. The paper gives the total as $55 million; the three parts it lists add up to $55.3 million. It does not name the lenders.
What the receiver told the court, January 2008
The receiver's report to the court of January 25, 2008, sets out the state of both projects. Altus Helyar, the quantity surveyor, a firm that estimates building costs, put the cost to finish Garden City at $12.3 million and H&H at $21 million as of December 31, 2007. The report expected Garden City to be finished by June 30, 2008, floors 1 to 13 of H&H by the same date, and the H&H penthouse floors by September 30, 2008.[4]
The report lists other problems. Hydrocarbons from the old gas station had leached into the ground under Helmcken Street, so the receiver planned a gravel trench with a vent pipe and a drain to the City sewer, at an estimated $85,000 plus $10,000 a year for testing. In Richmond, the roof in the permit drawings was drawn for a wood-frame building while the tower was concrete, a curb built by another developer at Cook Road and Katsura Street was offset by one metre from the company's work, and a flood in the tower caused damage the receiver put at less than $50,000.[4]
The construction lender, bcIMC, held $18.4 million of debt on Garden City and $47 million on H&H. The receiver accepted an offer from Century Services Inc. to lend $3.72 million for Garden City and $3.9 million for H&H, subject to court approval. Travelers Guarantee Company of Canada was the home warranty insurer for both projects, and Menko Construction Ltd. was to manage construction. Four firms sent proposals to sell the remaining homes, and two others declined to bid.[4]
The court ruling on presale contracts, 2008
The receiver asked the court for permission to cancel some presale contracts, the agreements buyers sign before a building is finished. In bcIMC Construction v. Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd., decided in 2008, Justice Burnyeat of the Supreme Court of British Columbia found that a receiver is bound by the companies' earlier contracts only if it chooses to be, and that it should ask the court before it cancels them. He also found that the two companies would stay liable for damages on any contract the receiver cancelled.[3]
The court found that these buyers held contract rights only and no interest in the land, because the contracts said so and because the buildings were not yet finished or divided into strata lots. The receiver's paper says an outside review of the H&H presales found 4 contracts "gifted" to buyers connected to the developer, 11 sold below market value at the date of sale, and 2 with no deposit held in trust. In Richmond, the review found 10 presales below market value, and the receiver cancelled all 10.[3]
Finishing and selling H&H, 2008
Provincial law requires a disclosure statement before presale homes are marketed, and gives buyers 7 days to cancel after receiving one. The paper says the receiver filed a new statement, and 15 presale buyers cancelled. It also says the receiver applied to the City for the penthouse change and bought 410 square feet of extra floor area, and the top floors were delayed by five months. The receiver's January 2008 report had given the extra area as 405 square feet.[29],[3],[4]
The City's record matches that account. On April 7, 2008, the Development Permit Board approved application DE411871 for 1133 Homer Street, which reduced the homes on the combined 15th and 16th floors from 6 to 4 and raised the allowed floor area through a heritage density transfer. Martin Bruckner of IBI/HB Group, the applicant, agreed to the staff conditions. No one else spoke, and the Board approved it without discussion.[25]
The paper says the building was finished in October 2008 and the receiver tried to close more than 170 sales within 30 days. After the financial crisis that September, 36 buyers did not complete. At the end of 2008, 50 homes were unsold, and the receiver sold all but 4 of them at one weekend sale advertised at up to 40 percent off earlier prices. BC Assessment gives 2008 as the year built for all 190 lots on the strata plan.[3],[14]
Finishing Garden City, 2008
When the receivership began, Garden City had 51 unsold units and $32 million of debt, by the receiver's account: $19 million at 7.75 percent a year and the rest at 16 to 24 percent. The cost to finish was estimated at $16 million. After the receiver issued a new disclosure statement, 5 presale buyers cancelled. With the 10 contracts the receiver had cancelled, it had 61 units to sell.[3]
The developer's vice president of construction stayed on as construction manager of the second tower, and the warranty provider asked the receiver to post $1 million of refundable security for new home warranty coverage. The paper says the second tower was finished in June 2008 and that every unit was sold and transferred to its buyer by August 2008. It says buyers could see the finished homes in the first tower, which made sales easier.[3]
The companies after 2009
The provincial registry lists Cook and Katsura Homes Inc. as historical since April 2009, Chandler Homer Street Ventures Ltd. since June 2009 and Chandler Development Group Inc. since July 2009. The City's business licence records mark the 2008 licences of both Vancouver companies as gone out of business. None of the three companies has an active entry in the registry today.[11],[10],[5],[6]
The building they started stands as H&H at 1133 Homer Street. On the City's 2026 tax roll, its strata plan, BCS3027, holds 190 lots: 175 at 1133 Homer Street and 15 townhomes with their own Homer and Helmcken Street addresses. Property management and listing sites still list Chandler Development Group Inc. as the developer of H&H, Tribeca Lofts and Hamlin Mews.[14],[30],[21]
Mark Chandler's later court record
Mark Chandler later developed Murrayville House in Langley through a different company, 0981478 B.C. Ltd., which also went into receivership, again with The Bowra Group Inc. as receiver. Business in Vancouver reported that on April 4, 2018, Justice Shelley Fitzpatrick of the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled that the receiver should sell 40 of its homes at market value to repay lenders. The judgment found that the developer had sold 151 presale contracts for 91 units, according to the same report.[8]
In the United States, Mark Chandler pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud over a planned condo project on Hill Street in Los Angeles between 2009 and 2011. The Langley Advance Times reported in February 2021 that Judge Percy Anderson sentenced him to six years in prison and ordered him to pay $1.7 million in restitution. The same paper reported that he has never been criminally charged or convicted in Canada.[31],[9]