7 chapters
The Pacific Western Realty Corporation story
From the public record, in time order. Each number in brackets links to its source.
Pacific Western Realty Corporation in the public record
The City of Vancouver's planning report of February 21, 1986, says the plan for the southeast corner of Thurlow and Alberni Streets was prepared by the architects Aitken Smith Carter Partners for Pacific Western Realty Corporation. At the public hearing on April 17, 1986, the architect David Aitken told Council he represented a development group, Pacific Western Developments. The records we read do not explain how those two names relate.[1]
OrgBook BC, the Province's public list of registered businesses, has one entry with the exact name Pacific Western Realty Corporation. It is a BC company, number BC0267671, registered on August 12, 1983. The registry gives August 30, 1985 as the date its current name took effect. The registry has listed it as historical, meaning no longer active, since March 12, 2003. We found no exact entry for Pacific Western Developments from the 1980s. We found no company website, news article or award that describes the company or its other projects.[3]
A parking lot at Thurlow and Alberni, early 1986
The site measured 2,386.4 square metres (25,676 sq ft) and was in use as a temporary surface parking lot. The City called it the former 1090 Alberni Street and 752 Thurlow Street. It sat in a half-block strip between the tall office towers of the downtown core, where buildings could reach 450 feet, and the lower Robson Street area across the lane, where the limit was 70 feet. Across Alberni stood the Continental Bank Building and the 21-storey Grosvenor Building, and across the lane stood the four-storey Manhattan apartments. Across Thurlow Street was the five-storey John Adams parking garage, with restaurants and the City Stage Theatre. To the east lay a surface parking lot, the Kobe restaurant building and a large excavated site where the Imperial Group had planned an office building, then on hold.[1]
The historian Eve Lazarus wrote that the corner once held a house where the Garden family lived by 1894, and that 752 Thurlow Street was later the Vancouver Women's Building and, from 1941, a Salvation Army building. The Manhattan across the lane dates from 1908, the Vancouver Heritage Foundation says, and residents formed a housing co-op there after a 1979 plan to demolish it.[7],[8]
Thurlow at Alberni: the plan of January 30, 1986
The Downtown District rules allowed a floor space ratio of 7.0 on the site, meaning floor area of seven times the site area, but homes could take only 3.0. The company's architects kept the total at 7.0 and asked for 5.0 for homes and 2.0 for shops, through a CD-1 zone, a zone written for one site. Their plan showed an 18-storey tower of homes over a two-storey base of 51,352 sq ft, with a food court below the street, a small food market, shops and second-floor restaurants, and no offices.[1]
City staff estimated the tower could hold up to 150 homes, depending on the mix of sizes. A third-floor amenity level separated the homes from the shops, and the homes had their own entrance on Alberni Street, with 145 parking spaces below ground. Staff asked the architects to design for future office towers to the east, so the wide faces of the tower were set at right angles to the eastern property line and most living room windows faced west.[1]
The Urban Design Panel supported more homes and the basic design, and asked for more work on the street front and on how the tower met its base. The City Engineer asked for a fix to a shortfall in parking and a new drop-off design on Alberni Street. The Director of Planning recommended approval, and wrote that the company had commissioned detailed market studies, which is the company's claim as the report records it.[1]
“The applicant has demonstrated that a residential density of 5.0 FSR can be made to work on this particular site, and the substitution of residential density for commercial potential is consistent with the general intentions of both the 1975 Downtown Plan and the more recent Vancouver Plan.”
Office neighbours object, February and March 1986
On February 21, 1986, the day of the planning report, four letters reached Council from Grosvenor International Canada Limited, from the lawyers Lawrence & Shaw for the Prudential Assurance Company, owner of 1090 West Georgia Street, from Sun Life of Canada, and from Lehndorff Management for the Burrard Building at 1030 West Georgia Street. They said a tower of homes did not belong one block from Burrard and Georgia, that a zone for one site was poor planning, and that residents might one day oppose new office towers nearby.[1]
Council's Standing Committee on Planning and Development took up the application on March 6, 1986, with Alderman Ford in the chair. Speakers for the same four companies objected again, and one of their points was that office tenants would look into balconies full of bicycles and barbecues. David Aitken said the homes would bring people to the Robson Street area. The committee noted that the tower would not suit family housing, and sent the application to a public hearing.[1]
The public hearing of April 17, 1986
Deputy Mayor Davies chaired the hearing, with seven members of Council present. One speaker addressed Council, for the Manhattan Housing Co-op across the lane. The co-op generally supported the plan, and asked that the parking not be reached from the lane, which would face its north suites, and that the Manhattan, a heritage building, be protected during excavation. The chair noted letters from Grosvenor, Sun Life, Prudential's lawyers and Ashworth Developments withdrawing their earlier opposition.[1]
Alderman Eriksen moved approval, together with a change to the Sign By-law that the Director of Planning proposed, and the motion carried with Aldermen Brown and Puil opposed. Council passed By-law No. 5997 on May 13, 1986, signed by Mayor Michael Harcourt. It allows homes to replace commercial space up to a floor space ratio of 5.0 and sets a height limit of 91.44 metres (300 ft).[1],[6]
The 1988 change and The Carlyle
On March 22, 1988, Council approved a text change for 1080 Alberni Street, applied for by Aitken Wreglesworth Associates, so that floor area would be counted under the West End plan. That let part of the existing amenity area become storage for residents, with no change to the approved form of development. No one spoke, and Council passed By-law No. 6334 on April 12, 1988. The Winnipeg Architecture Foundation says Peter Wreglesworth moved to Aitken Smith Carter Partners in Vancouver in 1984 and later formed Aitken Wreglesworth Associates.[1],[4]
BC Assessment gives 1988 as the year built for all 147 lots on strata plan VAS2213, the plan of The Carlyle at 1060 Alberni Street. On the 2026 roll, 146 lots carry that address and one carries 1070 Alberni Street. condos.ca says the strata plan was registered on July 25, 1988. A City permit of January 2017 refers to the building as the Carlyle and describes shop and office space in its base.[2],[9],[5]
What the records leave out
We found no record from 1987 or 1988 that names the company that built The Carlyle, its general contractor, or a sale of the site after the rezoning. The listing site condos.ca credits Concord Adex and Concord Pacific. Retail Insider reported that Concord Pacific was the landlord of the building's retail podium in 2017. That report is about the shops, and it names no builder for the tower.[9],[10]
The registered strata plan at the Land Title Office names the owner who created the strata lots in 1988, and it would show whether that owner was Pacific Western Realty Corporation. This page lists the company because the City's 1986 records name it as the client for this site. If you hold records from the project, please send them to our team.[1],[2]